Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Police

Police facial recognition searches tripled in Massachusetts last year

State data show that police made 143 facial recognition searches in fiscal year 2026. But those numbers likely represent a significant undercount, a Shoestring investigation found.

A black-and-white image shows three people, their backs to the camera. The photo is very blurry and grainy.
A screenshot of surveillance footage shows three alleged suspects in the vandalism of South Hadley High School in 2025.

In May 2025, school leaders in South Hadley discovered that the town’s high school had been vandalized. Three young people had broken in, smashed stage lights in the auditorium, and caused some $2,500 in damage.

As police set about investigating the case, they ran into dead ends with the low-quality surveillance footage they pulled from cameras in the parking lot of a bank and at a 7-Eleven on the night of the crime. And that’s when town Detective Christopher Roberts contacted the New England State Police Intelligence Sharing Network to get access to a much more powerful — and controversial — technology: facial recognition software.

Robbins obtained a search warrant from Eastern Hampshire District Court, and submitted a request to state police to search the Registry of Motor Vehicles database of ID photos. The search found no matches, even though investigators submitted a “clarified” version of an image cropped from a CCTV camera with adjustments to brightness and contrast, in an attempt to highlight the suspect’s face.

However, a Shoestring analysis of state data has revealed that police use of facial recognition technology has increased significantly in Massachusetts in recent years — numbers that likely represent a significant undercount. It’s a finding that those concerned with police surveillance say undermines the public’s right to privacy and the need for transparency around police use of AI.

In 2020, Massachusetts passed a law requiring police to obtain a search warrant to conduct a facial recognition search in most cases. And in order to provide transparency over the process, the law also requires the state’s Executive Office of Public Safety and Security, the office which oversees the Massachusetts State Police, to publish a yearly tally of the number of biometric searches police made.

Those annual reports have indicated that facial recognition is not widely used by police in Massachusetts. In 2021, police reportedly only made one facial recognition search. There were eight in 2022, 14 in 2023, and 45 in 2024.

In response to a public records request, the agency refused to disclose information regarding the number of searches made in 2025 — a decision The Shoestring has appealed to the state’s supervisor of records. But the agency did provide data for fiscal year 2026. Between September 2025 and September 2026, a log of face recognition searches made by state and local police shows 143 searches were made — more than triple the number for fiscal year 2024.

Facial recognition searches can be performed to investigate any crime; state law does not limit its use that way. Largely, police have not used biometric searches to investigate violent crime, drug trafficking, or sex crimes, according to the state’s data. Last year, those made up just 14% of face searches, down from about 20% in 2024. In addition, police ran eight searches for deceased people last year.

But an investigation by The Shoestring has found that these numbers are almost certainly an undercount.


The Shoestring relies on reader support — not corporate owners or paywalls — to make independent news for western Massachusetts possible. If you value independent local journalism, please consider making a tax-deductible donation.


Each year’s log only includes searches performed against a database of driver’s license photos maintained by the Massachusetts Registry of Motor Vehicles. But records show this is not the only database police are searching. Agencies have made requests to the FBI and Department of Homeland Security, for example. In some cases, police have turned to asking favors from other police departments in states with more lax regulations, asking officers there to run searches for them.

It’s unknown how many of these additional searches police have made. The Massachusetts State Police did not immediately respond to a request for comment. The Executive Office of Public Safety and Security could not be reached for comment. Despite being the secretariat which oversees state police, the office does not have a listed communications officer, and multiple phone calls to the office’s main number went unanswered.

The Shoestring identified these outside agency requests when reviewing search warrant applications for searches that were disclosed.

In one case, an Auburn detective, Daniel Lamoreaux, submitted a request for a search warrant in Worcester District Court to attempt to identify a suspect alleged to have stolen $5,000 in plumbing tools from a Home Depot using a stolen credit card. The warrant was submitted to both Massachusetts State Police and the FBI.

State police searched the database of RMV photos and found no matches. Then, while still awaiting the results of the FBI search, Lamoreaux contacted a police officer in Snellville, Georgia, Cpl. Austin Saunders, who had been working on a similar string of thefts alongside the same Home Depot loss prevention employee. Saunders told Lamoreaux that “his state allows facial recognition searches, which he completed” and found the suspect’s social media account.

It’s unclear if Saunders ran the search at the request of Lamoreaux, which would be prohibited under Massachusetts law. Snellville police told The Shoestring that Saunders no longer worked there, and Lamoreaux did not respond to a follow up question sent via email.

About a week later, Lamoreaux wrote, the FBI facial recognition search found the same social media profile. The Shoestring could not confirm what database that the agency searched. Tools like Clearview AI use photos scraped from the internet and social media into massive databases of identified photos. Federal procurement records show the FBI contracts Clearview’s services, and a document obtained by the non-profit Southerners Against Surveillance Systems and Infrastructure shows police in nearby Atlanta using the tool to specifically identify photos from an Instagram account.

From the instagram account, Lamoreaux says he used an unidentified “open source” database to learn the name and addresses of a man who he came to believe was a Dominican rapper living in Wisconsin, and late last Spring, a judge approved an arrest warrant for that man. The Shoestring is not naming this person, because they could not be reached for comment and no arrest has been made in the case.

The log of facial recognition searches that the Executive Office of Public Safety and Security provided only lists the zero result turned up by Massachusetts State Police, not the subsequent FBI or Georgia facial recognition searches. This seems to be the norm for facial recognition searches run by state police. Of the 143 for which the state provided information, 80 failed to find a single potential match.

Kade Crockford, the director for technology and justice programs at the ACLU of Massachusetts, told The Shoestring that’s a good thing because “it indicates the police are using an accuracy threshold that is fairly high.”

“What many people might not realize is that police investigations involve images of often poor quality,” Crockford said. They gave the example of an image taken from a surveillance camera, which is “often not at eye level,” but mounted high on a traffic signal or light post.

“And people generally do not look directly at surveillance cameras with their full faces exposed, in broad daylight,” Crockford said. “Shadows, hats, sunglasses, angles — all of these things combine to make the images from surveillance cameras less than stellar for facial recognition comparison purposes.”

But police seem to be leaving out that they ran a search when that search finds no one. A search requested by Marshfield police, for example, was not referenced in a 3,000-word police report that described in detail the officer’s investigative process for identifying the alleged thief of a Ford Expedition.

When The Shoestring contacted that person’s lawyer, they said they were unaware of any face recognition search involved in the case.


+ posts

Jonathan Gerhardson is a journalist in western Massachusetts.

Email: jon.gerhardson@proton.me

You May Also Like

Transportation

The Link413 bus route's path through the hilltowns offers a big boost in connectivity to a small — but growing — number of riders...

Politics

Following the passage of Massachusetts' new public records ballot question, The Shoestring decided to brainstorm what we hope to obtain from the governor and...

Politics

Several independent and third-party candidates will be on the ballot in western Massachusetts on Tuesday at a time when Gallup found that a record-high...

Labor

Cooperative restaurants are rare, especially in the Voo's multi-stakeholder format — but current owners and staff are optimistic that the time is right to...

Copyright © 2022 The Shoestring. Theme by MVP Themes.